In modern football, set pieces serve as critical opportunities for teams to gain an edge. For Manchester United, however, they have often been a source of frustration. Defensively, they have struggled to repel threats, while offensively, their inability to convert chances has hindered their overall performance. This article explores the extent of Manchester United’s set-piece struggles, the underlying issues, and potential solutions to transform this weakness into a strength.
Defensive Frailties: Lessons from the West Ham Match
Manchester United’s susceptibility to set-piece goals was laid bare in their clash with West Ham on October 27, 2024. The match’s decisive moment came when M. de Ligt’s trip on D. Ings during a set-piece led to a VAR-awarded penalty, which J. Bowen confidently converted.
This incident was not isolated. Throughout the game, West Ham repeatedly exploited Manchester United’s weaknesses in aerial duels. For instance:
- In the 86th minute, a cross from C. Summerville found J. Bowen, whose header narrowly missed the target.
- Defenders struggled to track movements in the box, exposing a lack of coordination and awareness.
These patterns underline a pressing need to address defensive marking during set pieces, particularly against physically dominant opponents.
Offensive Inefficiency: Missed Opportunities Against Leicester
While defensive frailties are concerning, Manchester United’s offensive inefficiency from set pieces is equally problematic. The match against Leicester on November 10, 2024, exemplified this struggle.
Despite several well-positioned free kicks and corners, United failed to capitalize. Notable moments included:
- Casemiro’s header from a C. Eriksen cross in the 45th minute was saved comfortably by Leicester’s goalkeeper.
- Misplaced deliveries and a lack of sharp movements in the box hindered Manchester United’s ability to convert opportunities into goals.
The recurring inability to execute effective offensive set pieces suggests a disconnect between preparation and execution.
Individual Accountability: Key Performers Under the Microscope
Addressing set-piece struggles requires evaluating individual contributions:
- Casemiro: His aerial ability is a strength offensively, as demonstrated by his headed goal against West Ham. However, his defensive discipline needs refinement, as rash challenges can compromise the team’s structure.
- Bruno Fernandes: A reliable set-piece taker, Fernandes has shown inconsistency in delivering high-quality crosses and free kicks, limiting scoring chances.
- Center-Backs: Players like M. de Ligt and Raphaël Varane are expected to dominate aerial duels but have occasionally fallen short, particularly when marking physically imposing attackers.
Identifying and addressing these individual weaknesses through tailored training is critical for improvement.
Tactical Adjustments: Turning Weakness into Strength
To improve their set-piece performance, Manchester United must adopt a holistic approach:
Defensive Solutions:
- Mixed Marking Systems: Combining zonal and man-marking can enhance coverage and mitigate mismatches in aerial duels.
- Improved Organization: Defensive players need clearer roles during set pieces, supported by better communication to anticipate opponent movements.
- Focused Training: Drills aimed at reinforcing marking techniques and tracking attackers can improve consistency and reduce lapses.
Offensive Solutions:
- Dynamic Routines: Incorporate decoy runs, blocks, and unexpected movements to create space and disrupt defensive structures.
- Varied Delivery Options: Rotate set-piece takers to introduce unpredictability and test opposition defenses with different styles of delivery.
- Aerial Drills: Focus on enhancing heading accuracy and power to maximize scoring opportunities from well-delivered crosses.
Specialized Training: A Path to Mastery
Manchester United should dedicate specific sessions to mastering set-piece scenarios, focusing on:
- Sharpening defensive awareness
- Refining crossing accuracy and movement timing
- Enhancing aerial dominance through competitive drills
By integrating these elements into regular training, the team can build confidence and efficiency in set-piece situations.
Conclusion: Transforming Weakness into a Weapon
Set-piece struggles have been a recurring issue for Manchester United, but they also represent an opportunity for growth. By addressing defensive vulnerabilities, refining offensive execution, and incorporating targeted training, United can turn this area of weakness into a competitive advantage.
Achieving set-piece excellence demands a collective effort from players, coaches, and analysts. Through meticulous preparation and consistent application, Manchester United can unlock the full potential of these critical moments and strengthen their campaign for domestic and European success. Mastering set pieces could ultimately be the difference-maker in their pursuit of silverware.
